- Information
- AI Chat
Was this document helpful?
They Say/I Say Chapter 4
Course: Ink To Ideas (ENG 123)
15 Documents
Students shared 15 documents in this course
University: Savannah College of Art and Design
Was this document helpful?
CHAPTER 4: THEY I SAY/I SAY
“YES/NO/OKAY, BUT”
Three ways to respond
When writers take too long to declare their position relative to the views they summarized or
quoted, readers get frustrated wondering, “is this person agreeing or disagreeing?”
It’s always a good tactic to clearly state whether you agree, disagree or both. Readers get a strong
grasp of where you stand which’ll help them appreciate the complications you later on go to unfold
The best interpretations take strong stands relative to other interpretations
In any effective interpretation, you need not only state what you yourself take the work of art to
mean but to do so relative to the interpretations of other readers.
Disagree - And Explain Why
To turn into an argument, you need to give reasons to support what you say: because another’s
argument is based on faulty or incomplete evidence; because it rests on questionable assumptions;
because it uses flawed logic or contradicts with what you take to be the real issue.
The “duh” move – when you disagree on something that was obvious may have been taken as some
ground-breaking revelation.
If saying “duh” is too colloquial for your intended audience, we can write something like “It is true
that __________; but we already knew that.”
Templates for disagreeing with reasons
X is mistaken because she overlooks _____________.
X’s claim view that __________ rests upon the questionable assumption that ___________.
I disagree with X’s claim that __________ because, as recent research has shown
___________.
X contradicts herself/can’t have it both ways. On one hand, she argues ___________. On
the other hand she also says ___________.
By focusing on ___________, X overlooks the deeper problem of _____________.
You can use the “twist it” move where you agree with the opposing evidence but you show with a
twist of logic that this evidence actually supports your claim.
X argues for ____________ saying that (evidence). I agree that (evidence) which is exactly
why I say the we should _____________ (challenge)
Agree But With A Difference